Is it ok to create a podcast feed that links to an mp3 on someone elses site without that site’s permission?
Do you have an issue with that? Ethically? Legally?
Wait, don’t answer yet…
Gigadial.com is already doing this. You can create a radio station and select your favorite shows from existing podcasts to populate your station. Then gigadial creates an RSS/podcast feed that you or other people can subscribe to and they will receive the mp3′s from the site of the original podcast.
Is this in poor form?
Maybe you don’t think Gigadial is very controversial because most people who put out podcasts want to be downloaded as much as possible. But what about a situation where a site puts up a mp3, licenses it as free for download, but they don’t currently have it as part of a podcast feed?
Now, say someone else added that mp3 into their own podcast feed.
Is that not following good ethics?
Ok, so maybe you still think that is ok.
What if someone creates a podcast that contains several shows with topics that you are complete opposed to, and then in the middle of the feed they link to your show?
Some of the legal issues can be resolved by people placing clear licensing terms on their mp3′s. However, I think the ethics even less clear.
Personally, if people give permission to distribute their mp3 I don’t think there is anything ethically wrong with linking to it. However, I do have a problem with being associated with ideas that I don’t agree with. This doesn’t override my opinion that linking is ok, but I’m curious to hear what other people think.